Thursday, July 24, 2008

Is America an Empire

I have heard it said before and it was recently brought up in a debate that America is an "empire". I don't like the term for several reasons, because it seems to me that America is anything BUT an empire, so I looked it up.

Here are the 10 definitions of "empire" offered up by dictionary.com

1. a group of nations or peoples ruled over by an emperor, empress, or other powerful sovereign or government: usually a territory of greater extent than a kingdom, as the former British Empire, French Empire, Russian Empire, Byzantine Empire, or Roman Empire.
2. a government under an emperor or empress.
3. (often initial capital letter) the historical period during which a nation is under such a government: a history of the second French empire.
4. supreme power in governing; imperial power; sovereignty: Austria's failure of empire in central Europe.
5. supreme control; absolute sway: passion's empire over the mind.
6. a powerful and important enterprise or holding of large scope that is controlled by a single person, family, or group of associates: The family's shipping empire was founded 50 years ago.
7. (initial capital letter) a variety of apple somewhat resembling the McIntosh. –adjective
8. (initial capital letter) characteristic of or developed during the first French Empire, 1804–15.
9. (usually initial capital letter) (of women's attire and coiffures) of the style that prevailed during the first French Empire, in clothing being characterized esp. by décolletage and a high waistline, coming just below the bust, from which the skirt hangs straight and loose.
10. (often initial capital letter) noting or pertaining to the style of architecture, furnishings, and decoration prevailing in France and imitated to a greater or lesser extent in various other countries, c1800–30: characterized by the use of delicate but elaborate ornamentation imitated from Greek and Roman examples or containing classical allusions, as animal forms for the legs of furniture, bas-reliefs of classical figures, motifs of wreaths, torches, caryatids, lyres, and urns and by the occasional use of military and Egyptian motifs and, under the Napoleonic Empire itself, of symbols alluding to Napoleon I, as bees or the letter N.

Which, if any, of these do you think applies to the United States?

6 comments:

The White Family said...

You should do one on why America is also NOT a democracy as so many think we are.

Anonymous said...

ok, I'll take the bait..

the answer is yes.

read why from the mouth of a right-winger

Anonymous said...

sorry, that is a good article, but the wrong link (he is canadian)

here is the link I MEANT to post

JonesGardenBlog said...

Thanks for taking the bait.

I read both. The first tries to twist the meaning of Empire to suit his case, re-phrasing it to "empire-lite" and the second one is drastically out of date, basing his determination of America as an empire on the Rumsfeld/Bremer model that was being used in Iraq at the time and was ultimately replaced by the Petraeus/Crocker/McCain :) model that has been extremely successful.

I've never heard or read about an 'empre' who seeks nothing more than the prosperity, security, and even autonomy of the country that they have taken by force.

No offense, but I believe both arguments are either out dated or weak.

Anonymous said...

Like usual, we will have to agree to disagree. I am not sure how a simple change of battle plan in Iraq determines if an entire nation is an empire or not, but if that is your argument than bravo.

The painfully obvious point is that America is EVEN IN Iraq and a vast number of other foreign countries imposing its will militarily, idealogically, and culturally. No person can dispute that fact and if there is anything that I took from my Justice Studies/Policy Sci college education it is that THAT is the modern definition of imperialism.

I really don't have time for this guilty pleasure, I may have to start avoiding your blog altogether. :)

JonesGardenBlog said...

I was actually just referencing the author's arguements of why he thought America was an empire.

That would be a bummer if you stopped reading the blog. I find our 'conversations' very interesting.

I have been reading the book you recommended, The Myth of a Christian Nation. I liked his intro, but I have not been digging the rest so far. I am hoping that he explains himself further as he goes.

I guess I'll have to update with a book report when I finish.

 
Clicky Web Analytics